Peer Review Process

The peer-review process is a cornerstone of scholarly publishing that ensures the quality and credibility of the articles published in the International Journal Of Economic, Management, Business, and Accounting (IJECOMBA). The following outlines the steps involved in the peer review process:

1. Submission:

  • Authors submit their manuscripts to the journal through an online submission system.

2. Initial Editorial Check:

  • The editorial team, led by the Editor-in-Chief, conducts an initial assessment to ensure the manuscript adheres to the journal's guidelines and scope.
  • Manuscripts that meet the basic criteria proceed to the next stage.

3. Peer Review Assignment:

  • The Editor-in-Chief assigns the manuscript to one or more qualified peer reviewers based on their expertise in the subject matter.
  • Reviewers are selected for their knowledge, experience, and impartiality.

4. Peer Review:

  • Peer reviewers thoroughly evaluate the manuscript, considering factors such as originality, methodology, relevance, and clarity of presentation.
  • Reviewers provide constructive feedback, suggestions for improvement, and a recommendation regarding acceptance, revision, or rejection.

5. Author Revisions:

  • Authors receive feedback from peer reviewers and are given the opportunity to revise their manuscripts.
  • Authors may address reviewers' comments, clarify points, and make necessary improvements.

6. Second Review (if needed):

  • Revised manuscripts may undergo a second round of review to ensure that concerns raised by reviewers have been adequately addressed.

7. Editorial Decision:

  • The Editor-in-Chief, in consultation with the editorial board, makes a final decision based on the peer reviewers' recommendations and the overall quality of the manuscript.
  • Possible decisions include acceptance, acceptance with minor revisions, major revisions, or rejection.

8. Publication:

  • Accepted manuscripts undergo final preparations for publication, including formatting and proofreading.
  • Published articles are made accessible through the journal's open-access platform, ensuring widespread dissemination of scholarly knowledge.

The peer-review process at IJECOMBA is designed to maintain the academic rigor of the journal, foster scholarly exchange, and contribute to the advancement of knowledge in the fields of Economics, Management, Business, and Accounting.